Choosing Kitchen Knives

How to pick a good kitchen knife set?

Pick a good kitchen knife set by focusing on the knives you'll use, judging the chef's knife first, checking steel and handles, and avoiding filler pieces.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. Start with the knives you’ll actually use
  3. Judge the set by its chef’s knife
  4. Steel and construction
  5. Handles and comfort
  6. Storage: block, magnetic strip or drawer
  7. Steak knives: serrated or straight
  8. Red flags on the box
  9. Pre-built set vs building your own
  10. How much to spend on a set
  11. A quick checklist

The short answer

A good kitchen knife set is built around a few knives you’ll actually use, usually a chef’s knife, a paring knife and a serrated bread knife, all made from decent steel with comfortable handles, plus storage that suits your kitchen. Smaller, well-chosen sets usually give better value than big blocks padded with knives that sit unused.

Start with the knives you’ll actually use

The core three

  • Chef’s knife (or santoku): does most of the work: chopping, slicing, dicing and mincing
  • Paring knife: peeling, trimming and small, precise jobs
  • Serrated bread knife: bread, tomatoes and foods with a tough skin and a soft inside

Many cooks prepare almost everything with just these three.

Useful extras

Add these only if they match how you cook (our guide to the types of kitchen knives explains what each one is for):

  • Utility or petty knife: a mid-size knife for sandwiches, small produce and trimming
  • Boning knife: if you break down chicken or trim meat often
  • Carving or slicing knife: if you regularly carve roasts
  • Kitchen shears: handy for herbs, packaging and spatchcocking poultry
  • Honing rod: useful for softer Western knives

Common filler

Large sets sometimes include several very similar utility knives, novelty specialty knives, or six or eight steak knives that inflate the “piece count”. The block itself and the shears are usually counted as “pieces” too.

Judge the set by its chef’s knife

The chef’s knife is the one you’ll use daily, so it should be good enough that you’d happily buy it on its own. A practical test: look up the individual price of the set’s chef’s knife, paring knife and bread knife. If those three alone cost about the same as the whole set, the extras are close to free. If the set costs much more, you’re paying for pieces you may not need.

For what makes a chef’s knife good, see our guide to choosing a chef’s knife.

Steel and construction

  • Steel: High-carbon stainless steel from an established maker is a sensible default. Harder steels hold an edge longer but can chip; softer steels are tougher and easier to sharpen. See the sharpest kitchen knives and the ones that stay sharp for more.
  • Edge geometry: Thin behind the edge slices more cleanly than thick.
  • Forged vs stamped: Both can be good; it mostly affects weight, bolster and price. Our forged vs stamped comparison explains the differences.
  • Bolster: A full bolster that runs down to the heel can make the back of the edge harder to sharpen over time. A slim or half bolster avoids this.
  • Tang and fit: Look for tight handles with no gaps. Our tang guide covers what to check.

Handles and comfort

Hold the chef’s knife in a pinch grip if you can. Check that the handle is secure when wet, that nothing digs into your fingers, and that the weight feels manageable. Comfort is personal; a set that suits a friend may not suit you.

Storage: block, magnetic strip or drawer

  • Knife block: convenient and protective, but takes counter space and only fits the knives it was made for.
  • Magnetic strip: saves counter space and lets you mix brands. Place and remove knives spine-first to avoid knocking the edge.
  • In-drawer organiser: keeps counters clear; useful in homes with children if combined with a drawer lock.
  • Blade guards: cheap protection if knives must go loose in a drawer.

Avoid loose knives rattling in a drawer. It dulls edges and is a cut risk. Our comparison of magnetic strips, knife blocks and drawers covers the trade-offs in more detail.

Steak knives: serrated or straight

  • Serrated steak knives stay “grippy” for a long time with little maintenance, but they tear meat slightly and are hard to resharpen.
  • Straight-edge steak knives cut more cleanly and can be sharpened, but they dull faster on ceramic plates.

If you rarely serve steak, consider skipping steak knives in the set and buying them separately later.

Red flags on the box

  • A very high piece count at a very low price
  • “Never needs sharpening” (usually means serrated blades throughout)
  • Steel that’s described only vaguely, such as “surgical” or “premium” stainless, with no grade given
  • Decorative Damascus patterns on very cheap knives
  • Self-sharpening blocks presented as a substitute for good steel (they’re convenient, but they don’t fix a poor knife)

Pre-built set vs building your own

A pre-built set is convenient, matches visually, can be good value during sales, and makes a good gift.

Building your own lets you choose the best chef’s knife for your hand and budget, then add inexpensive paring and bread knives from any brand. Many cooks find this gives better performance for the same money. A magnetic strip or universal block holds mixed brands.

For gifts or a first kitchen, a small three-to-five-piece set from a reputable maker is a sensible middle ground.

How much to spend on a set

Spend most of the budget on the chef’s knife. Paring and bread knives don’t need to be expensive to work well. As a rough guide, a solid small set from a reputable maker can cost less than a single premium chef’s knife. For price tiers, see how much you should spend on a chef’s knife. If you’re starting with a very small budget, our look at knives under $20 shows what’s realistic.

A quick checklist

  • Includes a chef’s knife you’d buy on its own
  • Includes a paring knife and a serrated bread knife
  • Few or no duplicates and novelty knives
  • Steel grade stated clearly, from a reputable maker
  • Comfortable, secure handles with no gaps
  • Storage that fits your counter or drawer
  • A way to keep the knives sharp, such as a honing rod, a sharpener or a sharpening service

If you’re buying for someone with weak or painful hands, see our guide to kitchen knives for seniors and weak hands, since lighter knives and different handles may matter more than the set itself.

The complete guide to choosing kitchen knives

Best Chef's Knives: How to Choose One
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →