Pocket Knife Brands

What is a Camillus knife worth?

What a Camillus knife is worth depends on whether it's an old New York-made knife or a modern import. Rough value ranges, value factors and how to check prices.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. First: is it an old New York Camillus or a new one?
  3. Rough value ranges by category
  4. What raises or lowers value
  5. How to research your knife’s value
  6. Don’t clean or sharpen it first
  7. Are Camillus knives good quality?

The short answer

Most Camillus knives are worth modest amounts, often somewhere from a few dollars to a few tens of dollars. Some are worth much more:

  • Modern Camillus knives, made after the brand was sold in 2007, are budget tools. Used ones sell for a fraction of the new price.
  • Common vintage New York-made pocket knives in average used condition usually sell for modest sums.
  • Military knives, scarce patterns and near-mint vintage examples can sell for considerably more, sometimes in the low hundreds of dollars. The best, rarest pieces sell for more than that.

These are rough guides. The real value of your knife is what similar knives have actually sold for recently.

First: is it an old New York Camillus or a new one?

The original Camillus Cutlery Company made knives in Camillus, New York, until its factory closed in 2007. The brand was then bought by Acme United, and current Camillus knives are made overseas, mainly in China. Collectors are almost entirely interested in the old New York knives.

To tell them apart:

  • Old New York knives typically have tang stamps such as “CAMILLUS NEW YORK U.S.A.”, “CAMILLUS CUTLERY CO. CAMILLUS N.Y.” or similar. Older ones may have other trade names the company used.
  • Modern knives have modern styling, such as pocket clips, liner locks, coated blades and titanium-bonded finishes, and are marked with an overseas country of origin on the blade or packaging.

Camillus also made knives for other brands and retailers. A knife carrying another name may have been made by Camillus, and collectors sometimes value those for that reason. For the bigger story of American brands that moved production, see where pocket knife brands are made.

Rough value ranges by category

Prices move, and condition matters enormously, so treat these as broad guides.

Modern Camillus knives

New knives from the current brand are budget to mid-priced, and used ones generally sell for well under their retail price. They’re tools, not collectibles.

Vintage pocket knives

Common New York-made patterns, such as jack knives, stockmans, Barlows and scout or utility knives in used condition, often sell for modest amounts, commonly in the tens of dollars. Clean examples with good handles, full blades and snappy springs sit at the higher end of that range or above it.

Military and contract knives

Camillus made large numbers of knives for the US military, including:

  • Four-blade utility knives (can opener, screwdriver/bottle opener, punch and blade), a classic GI pattern.
  • Electrician’s knives such as the TL-29 pattern.
  • Fixed-blade combat and survival knives, including WWII-era Mark 2-style fighting knives and pilot survival knives.

Military pieces with clear dates and markings, original sheaths and good condition tend to bring more than ordinary civilian pocket knives. In a forum thread on Camillus pricing, collectors put a mint, decades-old bone-handled pocket knife in roughly the $150 to $200 range. That’s a useful reminder that even good examples have limits.

Scarce patterns and near-mint examples

Rare variations, short production runs, unusual handle materials and knives that are unused and still in their original boxes can sell for much more than typical examples. Claims that a knife is “the rarest” or “one of a kind” need evidence, though. Collectors are skeptical of big claims without documentation, and so should you be.

What raises or lowers value

Raises value:

  • New York manufacture and clear, crisp tang stamps
  • Full, unsharpened or lightly sharpened blades
  • Tight joints, good spring tension, blades that sit level
  • Intact handles with no cracks, chips or shrinkage
  • Original box, sheath or paperwork
  • Military markings or scarce patterns

Lowers value:

  • Heavily sharpened blades with lost profile, or broken tips
  • Rust pitting (light patina is fine and often preferred)
  • Cracked or replaced handles
  • Weak or broken springs, loose blades
  • Aggressive polishing or buffing

How to research your knife’s value

  1. Record the details. Write down the exact tang stamp on each blade, the pattern number if there is one, the handle material and the number of blades.
  2. Search sold listings, not asking prices. Online auction sites let you filter for completed sales. Asking prices are often unrealistic.
  3. Compare like with like. Match the pattern, the era of the stamp and the condition as closely as you can.
  4. Ask collectors. Pocket knife collector forums can identify patterns and eras from good photos. Many forums don’t allow valuation requests, so ask about identification and then do your own price research.
  5. For valuable pieces, consider showing them to an experienced dealer or taking them to a knife show.

Don’t clean or sharpen it first

It’s tempting to polish an old knife before selling it, but collectors usually prefer original condition. Sharpening removes blade steel. Buffing can round off stamps and damage handles. Rust removers can leave an obviously “cleaned” look. If you want to stabilize a knife, wipe it with a little light oil and leave it at that.

Are Camillus knives good quality?

Vintage New York Camillus knives have a solid reputation as well-made working knives. The company produced huge numbers for civilians, scouts and the military for more than a century. Modern Camillus knives are a different proposition: affordable imported tools that are fine for light use but not comparable to the old knives as collectibles.

If your knife turns out to be a Schrade, Old Timer or Imperial instead, see Imperial and Schrade knives: who made them and how to identify them. For dating a Case, see how to date a Case knife by its tang stamp.

The complete guide to pocket knife brands

Where Pocket Knife Brands Are Made: USA, China and Beyond
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →