The short answer
You give a penny, or any small coin, in return for a gifted knife so the exchange becomes a symbolic purchase rather than a gift. According to a long-standing superstition, giving someone a knife can “cut” or sever the relationship between giver and receiver. Paying a token amount means you’ve bought the knife, so the bad luck doesn’t apply and the friendship stays intact.
It’s folklore, not fact. Many people still enjoy the ritual as a thoughtful, lighthearted part of giving a knife.
Where the superstition comes from
The exact origin isn’t clear, and you’ll find many competing claims. What’s widely reported is that versions of the custom show up in many places, including parts of Europe and Asia. The common thread is the symbolism of a blade as something that cuts, and so might cut a bond.
The custom is particularly well known in France. Makers such as Opinel and Laguiole forges describe the coin exchange as a traditional part of giving one of their knives. It’s also familiar in the UK, the US and elsewhere, and is often passed down in families or among knife enthusiasts.
Some explanations add that knives were once valuable, important tools, so a gift of one carried weight. Turning it into a small transaction kept things balanced. Treat these as traditional explanations rather than settled history.
How the coin exchange works
The process is simple, and there are two common versions:
- The giver includes a coin. The knife is given with a coin taped to the box or tucked inside. The recipient takes the coin and hands it straight back to the giver as “payment.”
- The recipient supplies the coin. The recipient gives the giver a coin from their own pocket when they receive the knife.
Either way, the point is that money changes hands, so the knife is “sold” rather than given. Including the coin yourself saves the recipient the awkwardness of searching their pockets, which is why many people prefer the first version.
Does it have to be a penny?
No. Any coin works, and the smallest local coin is traditional. In the US that’s a penny. Elsewhere it might be a one-cent euro coin or similar. Some people use a special or old coin to make it a keepsake. What matters is the symbolic payment, not the value.
What if you forget?
Nothing happens. It’s a superstition. If you or the recipient care about the custom, you can simply exchange a coin later, and many people consider that just as good. If neither of you minds, there’s no need to do anything.
Related knife superstitions
The penny custom sits alongside other knife beliefs that you may come across. Like the coin custom, these are traditions, not rules:
- Some people believe a folding knife should be closed by the person who opened it.
- Some say you shouldn’t hand someone an open knife, and that you should set it down for them to pick up. This one also makes good safety sense.
- Some families consider dropping a knife to be a sign that a visitor is coming.
Customs differ between families and regions, so you’ll find plenty of variations.
Tips for giving a knife as a gift
- Check the law. Make sure the knife is legal for the recipient to own and carry where they live. Our guide to blade length and knife laws is a starting point.
- Choose for their use. A slim folder suits office and light daily tasks. A small fixed blade may suit someone who camps or hunts. See best EDC knives for ideas, and fixed vs folding knives if you’re unsure which type to choose.
- Think about the mechanism. Locks and openers vary in how easy they are for beginners. Pocket knife lock types explained can help.
- Include the coin. Tape a coin inside the box with a short note explaining the custom. It’s a small touch that many recipients appreciate.