The Short Answer
- Choose a santoku if you want one versatile knife for meat, fish and vegetables, or a shorter, lighter alternative to a chef’s knife.
- Choose a nakiri if you cut a lot of vegetables, like fast up-and-down chopping, and already have another knife for meat and detail work.
The santoku is a generalist. The nakiri is a vegetable specialist. If you can only buy one and you cook a bit of everything, the santoku is the safer choice.
Santoku vs Nakiri at a Glance
| Santoku | Nakiri | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | All-purpose | Vegetables |
| Typical length | About 6.5–7 in (165–180 mm) | About 6.5–7 in (165–180 mm) |
| Edge profile | Mostly flat with a gentle curve near the tip | Flat from heel to tip |
| Tip | Pointed “sheepsfoot” that curves down to the edge | Blunt, squared-off front |
| Main cutting motions | Push cuts, chopping, light rocking, tip work | Straight up-and-down chopping and push cuts |
| Good for meat and fish? | Yes, boneless | Not really |
| Good for detail work? | Reasonably, using the tip | Limited, as there’s no point |
| Edge | Usually double bevel (sharpened on both sides) | Double bevel |
Sizes vary by maker, and some santoku and nakiri are shorter or longer than these typical ranges.
What Is a Santoku?
The santoku is a Japanese all-purpose kitchen knife that became popular in Japan in the mid-20th century as a home cook’s knife, and it’s now made by knife companies all over the world. The name is commonly translated as “three virtues”, which is usually explained as being good with meat, fish and vegetables, or as slicing, dicing and mincing.
Its blade is fairly tall, with a mostly flat edge and a spine that curves down to meet the edge at the tip. That shape is called a sheepsfoot. Many santoku have scalloped hollows (a Granton edge) along the side to help food release. Compared with a typical 8-inch Western chef’s knife, a santoku is usually shorter and often lighter, which many people find easier to control.
What Is a Nakiri?
The nakiri is a traditional Japanese vegetable knife. It has a thin, rectangular blade with a completely flat edge and a squared-off or slightly rounded front. “Nakiri” is often translated as “leaf cutter” or “vegetable cutter”.
Because the edge is flat, the whole length meets the cutting board at once. When you chop straight down, it cuts all the way through. You don’t get the “accordion” effect, where slices of scallion or cucumber stay joined at the bottom because a curved blade didn’t quite reach the board.
Key Differences
Edge Profile and Cutting Motion
This is the main difference. A nakiri is built for straight up-and-down chopping and forward or backward push cuts. It doesn’t rock at all, because there’s no curve.
A santoku also suits push cuts and chopping, but its gentle curve near the tip allows a limited rocking motion. It doesn’t rock as smoothly as a curved Western chef’s knife, though.
If you’re used to rocking a chef’s knife, a nakiri takes some adjustment. Many people find that once they’re used to it, it’s fast and precise for vegetables.
Tip
The santoku’s pointed tip is useful for scoring, making small cuts, and working into the corners of an onion or around the stem of a pepper. The nakiri’s blunt front can’t do those jobs well, but it’s less likely to catch or stab.
Versatility
A santoku handles boneless meat, fish, vegetables, herbs and cheese, which is why many people use it as their main knife. A nakiri can technically slice boneless meat, but it isn’t designed for it, and the lack of a point makes it awkward for trimming and portioning.
Neither knife is meant for cutting through bone, frozen food or very hard rinds. Thin Japanese blades can chip if used that way.
Blade Height and Knuckle Clearance
Both knives have tall blades that keep your knuckles off the board and let you scoop up chopped food. A nakiri’s height is consistent all the way to the front, which makes it particularly good as a scoop.
Which One Should You Buy?
- You want one knife for everything: santoku (or a chef’s knife or gyuto).
- You cook mostly vegetables or plant-based meals: a nakiri is a joy to use, ideally alongside a paring knife for detail work.
- You find an 8-inch chef’s knife too big: a santoku is a good, more compact alternative.
- You already have a chef’s knife you like: a nakiri adds more than a santoku does, because it does something different.
- You like rocking cuts for herbs: stick with a curved chef’s knife; neither knife rocks well.
Do You Need One If You Already Own a Chef’s Knife?
Not necessarily. A good chef’s knife does everything a santoku does, and most of what a nakiri does. A santoku mainly makes sense as an alternative to a chef’s knife, not an addition. A nakiri is a genuine addition if you prep a lot of vegetables and enjoy using a specialized tool.
If you’re weighing a Japanese-style chef’s knife instead, see gyuto vs Western chef’s knife. For the full range of kitchen knives and where each fits, see our guide to the types of kitchen knives.
Nakiri vs Usuba vs Chinese Cleaver
These three are easy to mix up:
- Nakiri: double-bevel (sharpened on both sides), aimed at home cooks, easy to use and sharpen.
- Usuba: a traditional professional vegetable knife with a single-bevel edge (sharpened mainly on one side). It’s capable of very thin, precise cuts but takes more skill to use and sharpen.
- Chinese vegetable cleaver (cai dao): taller and usually longer than a nakiri, used as an all-purpose knife in Chinese cooking for slicing, chopping and scooping. Despite the name, the thin vegetable versions aren’t for bone; heavier meat cleavers are a separate tool.
Using and Caring for Both
- Let the blade do the work. With a nakiri, use straight downward or slightly forward strokes; there’s no need to force it.
- Use the claw grip with your guiding hand, knuckles against the side of the blade. Our guide to the basic knife cuts covers julienne, dice and chiffonade, all of which suit these knives.
- Use a wood or plastic board. Glass, stone and ceramic boards dull and chip edges.
- Hand wash and dry. Dishwashers are hard on edges and handles. If your knife is carbon steel, dry it straight away to prevent rust.
- Sharpening: both are usually double bevel and easy to sharpen on a whetstone. The nakiri’s flat edge is particularly straightforward. Many Japanese knives are sharpened to a finer angle than Western knives, so check the maker’s guidance.