Knife Steel

S30V vs S35VN vs S45VN: CPM Knife Steels Compared

S30V, S35VN and S45VN are closely related CPM stainless steels. Compare their composition, edge retention, toughness, corrosion resistance and sharpening.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Where these steels came from
  3. Composition compared
  4. How they compare
  5. Summary table
  6. Does the difference matter in real use?
  7. Where MagnaCut fits
  8. Which should you buy?

Short answer

S30V, S35VN and S45VN are closely related powder metallurgy stainless steels from Crucible Industries, and each is best seen as a refinement of the last:

  • S30V is the original. It has good edge retention and corrosion resistance but is somewhat less tough and a bit harder to sharpen and finish.
  • S35VN adds niobium and reduces vanadium. It is generally regarded as slightly tougher and easier to sharpen, with similar or slightly lower edge retention.
  • S45VN raises chromium for somewhat better corrosion resistance, while keeping S35VN-like toughness and broadly similar edge retention.

In everyday use, the differences are modest. Heat treatment, hardness and blade geometry often matter more than which of the three a knife uses.

Where these steels came from

CPM S30V was introduced around 2001. Crucible developed it with input from knifemakers, notably Chris Reeve, as a stainless steel designed specifically for knives. It quickly became a standard premium steel in American production knives.

CPM S35VN followed around 2009. It was intended to improve on S30V’s toughness and make the steel easier to grind and polish.

CPM S45VN arrived later, around 2019–2020, as a further update with higher chromium.

All three are made with Crucible’s Particle Metallurgy (CPM) process, which produces small, evenly distributed carbides.

Composition compared

Approximate nominal compositions:

Element S30V S35VN S45VN
Carbon ~1.45% ~1.40% ~1.48%
Chromium ~14% ~14% ~16%
Vanadium ~4% ~3% ~3%
Molybdenum ~2% ~2% ~2%
Niobium — ~0.5% ~0.5%

The key changes are the niobium added in S35VN (with vanadium reduced from about 4% to 3%), and the extra chromium added in S45VN.

How they compare

Edge retention

S30V’s higher vanadium content gives it slightly more hard vanadium carbide, and it is often described as holding an edge a little longer than S35VN at the same hardness. S45VN is generally considered at least comparable to S35VN, and some testing places it slightly ahead. Across all three, the differences are small compared with the effect of hardness and edge geometry.

Toughness

Niobium forms very small, stable carbides that help refine the steel’s structure. Crucible positioned S35VN as tougher than S30V. Some sources cite a difference on the order of 15–20%, though independent testing suggests the real gap may be more modest. S45VN is generally regarded as similar to S35VN. None of the three is a particularly tough steel compared with CPM 3V or MagnaCut.

Corrosion resistance

S30V and S35VN have similar corrosion resistance and are good stainless steels for everyday carry. S45VN’s higher chromium gives it somewhat better corrosion resistance, which may matter if you live in a humid or coastal area. None of them is as corrosion resistant as specialist steels such as LC200N or H1.

Sharpening

All three are harder to sharpen than simple stainless steels such as 14C28N or 440C, and diamond or quality ceramic abrasives help. S35VN and S45VN are generally described as slightly easier to sharpen and to bring to a refined edge than S30V, which some users find can be stubborn to deburr.

Summary table

Ratings are relative to each other and assume similar hardness and heat treatment.

S30V S35VN S45VN
Edge retention Good+ Good Good to good+
Toughness Moderate Moderate+ Moderate+
Corrosion resistance Good Good Good+
Ease of sharpening Moderate− Moderate Moderate
Typical hardness ~58–61 HRC ~58–61 HRC ~59–61 HRC

For a reminder of what these hardness numbers mean, see knife hardness explained.

Does the difference matter in real use?

For most people using a pocket knife to open boxes, cut cord and handle general tasks, the three will feel very similar. You are more likely to notice differences in:

  • how thin the blade and edge are
  • the hardness the maker chose
  • how well the knife was heat treated and sharpened at the factory

If you’re choosing between two knives you like that differ only in these steels, pick the one with the design, ergonomics and price you prefer.

Where MagnaCut fits

CPM MagnaCut, released in 2021, has taken over many of the roles these steels once filled. In its designer’s published testing, MagnaCut showed higher toughness and better corrosion resistance than S30V, S35VN and S45VN, with broadly similar edge retention at comparable hardness. It is often found at similar or slightly higher prices. See MagnaCut steel: why knife makers are switching to it.

Which should you buy?

  • Choose S30V if you find a knife you like at a good price. It is still a capable steel.
  • Choose S35VN if you want a well-rounded, slightly more forgiving version of S30V.
  • Choose S45VN if you’d like a bit more rust resistance, for example in humid or coastal climates.
  • Consider MagnaCut if you want better toughness and corrosion resistance and the price difference is small.

For a broader view of how these compare with carbon, tool and other stainless steels, see our guide to the best knife steel, or is D2 steel good for knives? for a budget alternative.

The complete guide to knife steel

Best Knife Steel: What Metal Makes a Good Blade
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →